We got new wheels! These are OEM BMW E38 style 37 M Parallel. Of course they didn't fit well with the meaty tires we put on there so we had to cut the rear fenders and roll the front. Thanks to my friend Chris (@kuyaguchi) for the help!
Wheel Specs
Front: 18x8 +13 225/40/18
Rear: 18x9.5 +25 235/40/18