Thanks to shenanigans, I own 2 987 Porsche Caymans. With one 987.1 2008 Cayman S and one being a 987.2 2009 Cayman S. With a rather unique opportunity at hand, I figured this was a good time to offer a comparison between two very similar cars... for twice the price, does a 98.2 Cayman S give you that much more than one just a year older? Let's walk through it and find out!